Outrageous How To Write An Effective Referee Report
How to Write an Effective Referee Report and Improve the Scientific Review Process 235 problems that must be addressed before publication require rigorous justification.
How to write an effective referee report. I have commented below on each of the points raised by the referees. 3 April 2008 pp. National Bureau of Economic Research NBER.
Simply stating that you learned a lot throughout the course is not enough. Let the editors know if you need any additional information from the authors to help you write a balanced and well-substantiated report. Each has a different purpose and will require different arguments and evidence to achieve that purpose.
Say what is good about a piece of work and say how it can be improved. Harvey and David Hirshleifer in the Journal of Economic Perspectives. Explain the world or change it.
Heres a paper write a review. When the reflective report is about your learning experiences on the module be as specific as possible. An effective report does not waste the readers time.
The results constitute an argument usually in support of although sometimes refuting a hypothesis. Author Ushma S Neill. To educate the editor to convince the editor and other referees that youve actually read the paper no joke 2.
Thank you for the opportunity to revise my paper. The review process for academic journals in econ. Write your report in an understandable and organized way.